Appellate Attorneys - How Framing the Issues on Appeal Defines the Battleground

Posted on 11 December, 2014 at 15:45

An appellate attorney knows that in an appellate brief, how you choose to frame the appellate issues is incredibly important. In framing the appellate issues, you are setting forth the parameters of the legal battlefield. It is your job to establish the errors at trial that greatly prejudiced your client. Don’t be overly objective or too legalistic in framing the issues. Your job is to win the case for your client, and consequently frame the issues from his or her legal perspective. Also, do not make the issues overly complicated. 


Just as important, is to set the proper standard of review for which a judge forms his decision. That is, there are essentially two legal standards in the appellate world – abuse of discretion and de novo review. The abuse of discretion standard essentially asks whether a judge, within a wide latitude of judgment, properly exercised his discretion. The de novo standard asks whether a judge simply applied the correct law. 


In dealing with an abuse of discretion appeal, the appellate court will give great deference to the trial court. A reversal requires a judicial act of egregious proportions. A de novo appeal, on the other hand, simply asks whether a judge was right or wrong in making his decision. 


For instance, in State X, a plaintiff must file a motion to dismiss within 60 days of the filing of the initial lawsuit – no exceptions are permitted. The judge finds the lawsuit absolutely frivolous, and entertains a motion filed 95 days after the filing of the initial suit. Subsequently, the motion to dismiss is granted. You correctly argue that the de novo standard of review applies by simply explaining that the defendant failed to file the motion to dismiss within the correct time frame. You also correctly explain that the trial court judge had no discretion to extend the deadline date. The judge applied the law wrong, and applying the de novo standard of review, a reversal is required. 


In contrast, let us say a judge allows gruesome photographs at trial of a car accident in which the plaintiff’s left arm is severed and blood is splattered everywhere. You argue the photographs will prejudice the jury. You acknowledge the accident did occur, but that the plaintiff was speeding and that the plaintiff was the proximate cause of the accident – not your client. In any event, the judge allows these game changing photos into evidence. You would need to prove this was an egregious error in order for a reversal to take place in the appellate court. This is a tough hurdle to overcome. 


Many trial attorneys when arguing an abuse of discretion appeal will use trial tactics in an attempt to persuade an appellate court to grant a reversal. A trial court attorney will vociferously go into detail on what these photographs depicted. The trial attorney will note that two jurors asked to go to the bathroom after the pictures were introduced into evidence. Essentially, the trial court attorney will make a very powerful argument that the photographs greatly prejudiced the jury and that this was an abuse of the trial court’s discretion. Unfortunately, this argument will lose most of the time. 


The key here is to frame the legal issue in the correct manner. You want to make sure that the introduction of the photographs is reviewed under the de novo standard of review. How do you do that when in most instances the introduction of evidence is reviewed under the abuse of discretion standard? Well, you need to do a lot of research and frame the issues properly. After 50 hours of legal research, you find a case entirely on point. The case holds that where the defendant claims no liability, the introduction of gruesome photographs is not permitted. You then frame the issue as follows: The Trial Court did not correctly apply the law in allowing gruesome photographs at trial whereas this court has clearly held that emotionally evocative photographs cannot be introduced at trial in instances where contributory negligence is alleged. You just took away the trial court’s discretion and now have your opponent on the defensive. This was simply done by correctly framing the argument. 


In laymen’s terms, you hear that a neighbor was arrested for disciplining his child. Under the abuse of discretion standard, the issue would be framed that a parent has the right to discipline a child. However, in applying a de novo standard of review, the issue would be framed that no parent has the right to hit his child with a belt buckle 47 times causing severe bleeding and scars. As you can see, how the issues are framed defines the battleground on appeal. 


Written by:   John V. Siskopoulos, Esq.

Telephone:    (617) 959-1628 

Email:            [email protected] 


If you have a civil appeal or criminal appeal and would like to speak with an appellate attorney at Siskopoulos Law Firm, LLP, contact us at either (646) 942-1798 or (617) 959-1628.

Disclaimer: This Blog/Web Site is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

Categories: Appellate Attorneys

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply kyrie 6
3:11 on 5 February, 2021 
My wife and i got so more than happy Chris could finish off his homework from the ideas he had out of the web site. It is now and again perplexing to simply always be offering information and facts that the others have been selling. So we fully understand we need the blog owner to give thanks to for this. The type of explanations you have made, the easy blog navigation, the relationships your site aid to create - it is mostly astounding, and it's really facilitating our son and the family feel that that concept is excellent, which is quite pressing. Thanks for all!
kyrie 6
Reply golden goose outlet
6:02 on 7 February, 2021 
I in addition to my buddies have been examining the good helpful tips found on the blog then the sudden I got a terrible feeling I never expressed respect to the web site owner for those strategies. These people became totally happy to study them and have clearly been taking advantage of these things. I appreciate you for genuinely simply thoughtful and for going for this sort of quality resources most people are really desirous to be informed on. My very own sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to sooner.
golden goose outlet
Reply jordan 1 mid
22:00 on 7 February, 2021 
Thanks so much for providing individuals with an extraordinarily memorable opportunity to read in detail from this blog. It's always very nice and as well , full of a lot of fun for me and my office peers to search your website at minimum thrice in a week to learn the newest stuff you have got. And lastly, I am just certainly astounded with all the incredible tactics you give. Certain 4 areas in this posting are ultimately the most beneficial we have all ever had.
jordan 1 mid
Reply steph curry shoes
21:46 on 9 February, 2021 
I not to mention my pals appeared to be checking the good information and facts on the blog while the sudden came up with a horrible suspicion I had not thanked the website owner for those strategies. All the guys are actually for that reason excited to study all of them and already have simply been having fun with them. Many thanks for getting so considerate and then for choosing this sort of superior information millions of individuals are really needing to be aware of. Our own sincere apologies for not saying thanks to you earlier.
steph curry shoes
Reply off white
5:23 on 12 February, 2021 
I actually wanted to develop a brief comment in order to appreciate you for all of the superb guidelines you are showing at this site. My long internet lookup has at the end been honored with beneficial facts and techniques to go over with my great friends. I would declare that most of us site visitors are quite blessed to exist in a remarkable website with very many marvellous people with great techniques. I feel somewhat fortunate to have seen your website and look forward to tons of more enjoyable times reading here. Thank you once more for everything.
off white
Reply russell westbrook shoes
21:30 on 12 February, 2021 
I'm writing to make you know of the helpful discovery my girl developed viewing your webblog. She learned several pieces, with the inclusion of how it is like to have an awesome helping spirit to make other people really easily gain knowledge of various extremely tough topics. You actually exceeded people's desires. Many thanks for delivering these precious, safe, educational and easy tips on that topic to Julie.
russell westbrook shoes
Reply longchamp
18:52 on 14 February, 2021 
I intended to write you a little bit of word just to give many thanks again on your pleasing suggestions you've featured on this site. This has been quite strangely open-handed of you to convey easily what exactly numerous people might have offered as an e book to help make some cash for themselves, most importantly considering the fact that you could possibly have tried it in case you desired. The concepts also acted to become a great way to understand that other people online have a similar keenness much like my personal own to grasp a little more with reference to this condition. Certainly there are millions of more fun times ahead for people who look into your blog post.
Reply supreme new york
18:52 on 14 February, 2021 
My husband and i have been very joyous when Emmanuel managed to round up his analysis by way of the ideas he came across in your site. It's not at all simplistic to simply always be releasing secrets and techniques that most people might have been trying to sell. We really recognize we have the website owner to thank for this. Most of the explanations you made, the simple web site navigation, the relationships your site help to foster - it's got everything incredible, and it's really helping our son in addition to us reason why this content is brilliant, which is certainly really serious. Many thanks for all!
supreme new york
Reply supreme new york
18:54 on 14 February, 2021 
I precisely desired to appreciate you once again. I do not know what I could possibly have taken care of in the absence of the entire tips contributed by you relating to my area. It became a difficult matter in my view, but taking a look at this well-written style you resolved it took me to cry for delight. Now i am thankful for your guidance and then believe you realize what an amazing job that you are doing educating some other people through the use of a site. Most probably you've never come across all of us.
supreme new york
Reply hermes birkin
15:43 on 17 February, 2021 
I am only writing to let you be aware of what a brilliant encounter my daughter went through viewing your webblog. She noticed numerous issues, which included what it's like to have an awesome helping heart to get a number of people quite simply learn about a variety of extremely tough subject matter. You undoubtedly did more than visitors' desires. Thank you for delivering those essential, trustworthy, edifying and easy guidance on this topic to Tanya.
hermes birkin
Reply curry 6
12:40 on 18 February, 2021 
My wife and i got quite comfortable when Edward managed to deal with his analysis from the precious recommendations he got from your web pages. It is now and again perplexing to just continually be giving out tips and tricks that many some other people may have been selling. And we all acknowledge we now have the writer to be grateful to for this. Most of the illustrations you made, the simple site menu, the friendships you will help foster - it's many sensational, and it's really aiding our son and us reckon that that situation is satisfying, and that's exceptionally indispensable. Many thanks for everything!
curry 6
Reply pandora jewelry
15:21 on 20 February, 2021 
I truly wanted to type a simple word so as to thank you for all the pleasant tips you are writing here. My prolonged internet look up has now been paid with sensible insight to write about with my two friends. I would mention that we site visitors actually are really lucky to live in a wonderful network with very many lovely professionals with good guidelines. I feel really privileged to have come across your webpage and look forward to really more enjoyable moments reading here. Thank you again for everything.
pandora jewelry
Reply curry 8
11:41 on 24 February, 2021 
I wanted to draft you that very little observation in order to thank you so much yet again on the stunning concepts you've shared on this website. This is surprisingly generous of people like you to grant openly all that a lot of folks could possibly have offered as an ebook in order to make some profit for themselves, especially seeing that you might well have done it if you decided. Those concepts likewise served to be the great way to fully grasp that the rest have a similar keenness really like my very own to understand significantly more regarding this problem. Certainly there are numerous more fun periods in the future for many who looked over your blog.
curry 8
Reply yeezy shoes
13:32 on 27 February, 2021 
I simply wanted to post a remark to express gratitude to you for all of the lovely tricks you are placing here. My incredibly long internet research has at the end of the day been compensated with excellent concept to talk about with my friends. I would assume that we visitors actually are extremely fortunate to live in a very good network with so many special professionals with insightful tips and hints. I feel very much happy to have discovered the web pages and look forward to really more brilliant moments reading here. Thanks a lot once again for all the details.
yeezy shoes
Reply Clarkren
11:17 on 1 March, 2021 
79zan oyl0f ucu6
Reply kobe byrant shoes
7:31 on 2 March, 2021 
I actually wanted to jot down a simple message in order to say thanks to you for all the wonderful strategies you are sharing at this site. My time intensive internet look up has at the end of the day been recognized with sensible strategies to go over with my partners. I 'd point out that most of us website visitors actually are unequivocally endowed to dwell in a very good community with very many wonderful people with helpful secrets. I feel truly lucky to have come across your entire website page and look forward to really more exciting times reading here. Thanks once again for a lot of things.
kobe byrant shoes
Reply Lisaeromb
13:43 on 2 March, 2021 
cymbalta 20 mg coupon
Reply Pauleromb
20:30 on 2 March, 2021 
viagra 500mg kamagra online ciprofloxacin medicine cialis super active buy viagra cheapest price
Reply Kiaeromb
11:54 on 3 March, 2021 
cialis in women
Reply Carleromb
13:19 on 3 March, 2021 
northwest pharmacy canada ivermectin price where to buy female viagra in canada can you buy medrol over the counter stromectol 3 mg