Appellate Attorneys - How Framing the Issues on Appeal Defines the Battleground

Posted on 11 December, 2014 at 15:45

An appellate attorney knows that in an appellate brief, how you choose to frame the appellate issues is incredibly important. In framing the appellate issues, you are setting forth the parameters of the legal battlefield. It is your job to establish the errors at trial that greatly prejudiced your client. Don’t be overly objective or too legalistic in framing the issues. Your job is to win the case for your client, and consequently frame the issues from his or her legal perspective. Also, do not make the issues overly complicated. 


Just as important, is to set the proper standard of review for which a judge forms his decision. That is, there are essentially two legal standards in the appellate world – abuse of discretion and de novo review. The abuse of discretion standard essentially asks whether a judge, within a wide latitude of judgment, properly exercised his discretion. The de novo standard asks whether a judge simply applied the correct law. 


In dealing with an abuse of discretion appeal, the appellate court will give great deference to the trial court. A reversal requires a judicial act of egregious proportions. A de novo appeal, on the other hand, simply asks whether a judge was right or wrong in making his decision. 


For instance, in State X, a plaintiff must file a motion to dismiss within 60 days of the filing of the initial lawsuit – no exceptions are permitted. The judge finds the lawsuit absolutely frivolous, and entertains a motion filed 95 days after the filing of the initial suit. Subsequently, the motion to dismiss is granted. You correctly argue that the de novo standard of review applies by simply explaining that the defendant failed to file the motion to dismiss within the correct time frame. You also correctly explain that the trial court judge had no discretion to extend the deadline date. The judge applied the law wrong, and applying the de novo standard of review, a reversal is required. 


In contrast, let us say a judge allows gruesome photographs at trial of a car accident in which the plaintiff’s left arm is severed and blood is splattered everywhere. You argue the photographs will prejudice the jury. You acknowledge the accident did occur, but that the plaintiff was speeding and that the plaintiff was the proximate cause of the accident – not your client. In any event, the judge allows these game changing photos into evidence. You would need to prove this was an egregious error in order for a reversal to take place in the appellate court. This is a tough hurdle to overcome. 


Many trial attorneys when arguing an abuse of discretion appeal will use trial tactics in an attempt to persuade an appellate court to grant a reversal. A trial court attorney will vociferously go into detail on what these photographs depicted. The trial attorney will note that two jurors asked to go to the bathroom after the pictures were introduced into evidence. Essentially, the trial court attorney will make a very powerful argument that the photographs greatly prejudiced the jury and that this was an abuse of the trial court’s discretion. Unfortunately, this argument will lose most of the time. 


The key here is to frame the legal issue in the correct manner. You want to make sure that the introduction of the photographs is reviewed under the de novo standard of review. How do you do that when in most instances the introduction of evidence is reviewed under the abuse of discretion standard? Well, you need to do a lot of research and frame the issues properly. After 50 hours of legal research, you find a case entirely on point. The case holds that where the defendant claims no liability, the introduction of gruesome photographs is not permitted. You then frame the issue as follows: The Trial Court did not correctly apply the law in allowing gruesome photographs at trial whereas this court has clearly held that emotionally evocative photographs cannot be introduced at trial in instances where contributory negligence is alleged. You just took away the trial court’s discretion and now have your opponent on the defensive. This was simply done by correctly framing the argument. 


In laymen’s terms, you hear that a neighbor was arrested for disciplining his child. Under the abuse of discretion standard, the issue would be framed that a parent has the right to discipline a child. However, in applying a de novo standard of review, the issue would be framed that no parent has the right to hit his child with a belt buckle 47 times causing severe bleeding and scars. As you can see, how the issues are framed defines the battleground on appeal. 


Written by:   John V. Siskopoulos, Esq.

Telephone:    (617) 959-1628 

Email:            [email protected] 


If you have a civil appeal or criminal appeal and would like to speak with an appellate attorney at Siskopoulos Law Firm, LLP, contact us at either (646) 942-1798 or (617) 959-1628.

Disclaimer: This Blog/Web Site is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

Categories: Appellate Attorneys

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply longchamp
19:15 on 15 June, 2022 
I precisely desired to say thanks once more. I am not sure the things that I might have carried out in the absence of these ideas documented by you concerning my field. Previously it was a traumatic situation in my view, nevertheless being able to view this specialized avenue you resolved the issue made me to leap with delight. I'm just happy for your work and even hope that you comprehend what an amazing job that you're putting in teaching most people thru your websites. I am certain you've never encountered all of us.
Reply goyard outlet
19:39 on 16 June, 2022 
My husband and i have been very peaceful that Albert could round up his inquiry through your precious recommendations he acquired using your web pages. It is now and again perplexing to simply possibly be giving away guidance that some people have been selling. And now we fully understand we now have the writer to thank because of that. The main illustrations you made, the easy site menu, the relationships you give support to engender - it's got all astonishing, and it's leading our son and our family consider that that concept is satisfying, which is wonderfully serious. Thank you for all the pieces!
goyard outlet
Reply curry shoes
7:25 on 18 June, 2022 
I needed to create you this very small remark to say thanks the moment again with your exceptional suggestions you have documented on this site. This has been simply remarkably generous of you to grant freely just what most people might have made available for an e book to generate some bucks for their own end, certainly now that you could possibly have done it if you ever desired. The creative ideas additionally worked like a fantastic way to be aware that someone else have the identical dreams just like my personal own to learn significantly more with regard to this problem. I am certain there are a lot more pleasurable sessions in the future for many who looked over your blog post.
curry shoes
Reply steph curry shoes
20:58 on 24 June, 2022 
I precisely had to appreciate you once more. I do not know what I would have used in the absence of the thoughts shared by you over this situation. This has been a very alarming matter for me, nevertheless viewing this professional form you treated that made me to cry over happiness. I'm grateful for your assistance and even pray you realize what a powerful job you have been doing instructing people thru your blog post. Most likely you have never encountered any of us.
steph curry shoes
Reply nike off whtie
20:58 on 24 June, 2022 
My husband and i have been quite joyous Albert managed to complete his studies out of the ideas he discovered through the web site. It is now and again perplexing to simply happen to be offering secrets and techniques which often many people could have been making money from. Therefore we do know we now have the website owner to be grateful to for that. The specific illustrations you've made, the straightforward site navigation, the friendships you can give support to instill - it is all incredible, and it's really aiding our son in addition to our family consider that that content is amusing, which is rather fundamental. Many thanks for all!
nike off whtie
Reply jordan 13
20:59 on 24 June, 2022 
I simply wanted to develop a quick word to say thanks to you for these splendid strategies you are writing on this website. My incredibly long internet lookup has at the end been paid with reasonable ideas to exchange with my family and friends. I would express that we readers actually are undoubtedly blessed to be in a very good network with very many special individuals with great suggestions. I feel truly lucky to have used your entire website and look forward to some more enjoyable moments reading here. Thanks a lot again for all the details.
jordan 13
Reply jordan shoes
20:59 on 24 June, 2022 
My husband and i have been quite cheerful Jordan managed to deal with his studies through the ideas he got while using the weblog. It is now and again perplexing to simply be giving away helpful tips a number of people could have been trying to sell. Therefore we consider we now have the writer to thank for this. The specific illustrations you have made, the straightforward blog menu, the relationships you can assist to promote - it's got many fabulous, and it's really helping our son in addition to our family do think this topic is satisfying, and that's extremely indispensable. Many thanks for the whole lot!
jordan shoes
Reply steph curry shoes
21:00 on 24 June, 2022 
I needed to put you that little note to finally thank you very much over again just for the pretty views you've shared on this website. It was simply particularly open-handed of you to deliver freely exactly what a few individuals would've sold as an e-book to generate some profit on their own, chiefly seeing that you could possibly have tried it if you ever wanted. These thoughts in addition served to provide a great way to be certain that other people online have similar eagerness the same as my personal own to figure out very much more in regard to this problem. I know there are lots of more enjoyable situations in the future for individuals who look into your blog post.
steph curry shoes
Reply jordan shoes
21:00 on 24 June, 2022 
I am just writing to make you know of the nice experience my daughter undergone visiting the blog. She figured out several details, with the inclusion of what it is like to possess an excellent coaching style to get the rest easily thoroughly grasp some multifaceted issues. You really exceeded her expectations. Thank you for producing such invaluable, dependable, explanatory as well as unique tips about the topic to Janet.
jordan shoes
Reply Jasoneromb
23:08 on 29 June, 2022 
amoxicillin from canada
Reply goyard bags
23:19 on 29 June, 2022 
I together with my guys were actually looking at the best tricks on your web page and so the sudden got a terrible feeling I never thanked the web site owner for those techniques. These young boys became absolutely joyful to read them and have now without a doubt been making the most of those things. Appreciate your genuinely indeed accommodating and for opting for varieties of beneficial subjects most people are really desirous to be aware of. My personal honest regret for not expressing appreciation to you earlier.
goyard bags
Reply kyrie 7 shoes
9:50 on 1 July, 2022 
I really wanted to compose a simple word to be able to express gratitude to you for all of the fantastic solutions you are placing at this site. My particularly long internet research has at the end of the day been compensated with pleasant details to exchange with my two friends. I 'd declare that we site visitors are very much fortunate to be in a fine network with very many marvellous professionals with great techniques. I feel extremely grateful to have seen your website page and look forward to really more entertaining moments reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything.
kyrie 7 shoes
Reply moncler
19:39 on 5 July, 2022 
I would like to express some appreciation to the writer just for rescuing me from this type of predicament. After looking through the search engines and seeing things which were not powerful, I was thinking my life was gone. Being alive without the approaches to the difficulties you have resolved as a result of the guideline is a serious case, and the kind which may have negatively affected my career if I hadn't come across the blog. Your actual mastery and kindness in taking care of everything was very helpful. I am not sure what I would've done if I hadn't discovered such a stuff like this. I can at this point relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for your impressive and result oriented help. I will not be reluctant to suggest your web page to anybody who needs to have support about this issue.
Reply supreme clothing
4:01 on 7 July, 2022 
I simply had to say thanks yet again. I do not know the things that I might have accomplished without those advice revealed by you relating to my subject. Entirely was a horrifying dilemma in my position, but being able to see the very well-written way you dealt with it forced me to weep for happiness. Now i'm grateful for the service and trust you are aware of an amazing job you are always undertaking educating others all through your blog. Most probably you have never met any of us.
supreme clothing
Reply ElwoodLap
14:45 on 7 July, 2022 
triamterene 75 50 mg
Reply supreme shoes
14:05 on 8 July, 2022 
Thank you so much for providing individuals with an exceptionally spectacular possiblity to read from this blog. It is usually so amazing plus packed with a lot of fun for me and my office co-workers to search your website really 3 times every week to see the fresh items you have got. And definitely, I'm just always contented for the unique principles you serve. Some 3 facts in this article are honestly the most impressive we have all ever had.
supreme shoes
Reply ElwoodLap
15:45 on 8 July, 2022 
ivermectin coronavirus
Reply cheap kyrie irving shoes
16:50 on 8 July, 2022 
I enjoy you because of your entire effort on this web site. My mother delights in conducting internet research and it is easy to see why. My spouse and i know all about the lively medium you give worthwhile suggestions through your blog and as well improve contribution from people on the area of interest so our own daughter is undoubtedly understanding a great deal. Take advantage of the remaining portion of the new year. You're carrying out a stunning job.
cheap kyrie irving shoes
Reply yeezy 700
17:42 on 8 July, 2022 
Thank you for every one of your effort on this site. My daughter delights in carrying out investigations and it's easy to understand why. My partner and i know all about the dynamic means you make both useful and interesting thoughts on your web blog and as well as improve contribution from people about this point and our favorite child is in fact understanding so much. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. You are conducting a really good job.
yeezy 700
Reply cheap kyrie 7
17:44 on 8 July, 2022 
I needed to draft you the very small word to be able to give many thanks as before on the marvelous basics you have shown at this time. It has been quite tremendously open-handed of people like you to convey without restraint what a lot of people might have sold as an e book in making some money for themselves, and in particular considering that you could have tried it if you ever decided. These points in addition worked to become a great way to be sure that someone else have similar dreams similar to my own to understand a whole lot more in regard to this problem. I am certain there are many more enjoyable opportunities ahead for individuals that look into your site.
cheap kyrie 7